The Essential Four

Regular price$49.99
/

  • Perfect first order – Our 4 bestsellers!
  • 4 sealed bags – Fresh from our kitchen!
  • CiCi's "Love it" Guarantee
Handmade with real ingredients and 💛 – just like Nana did it!

Our 4 most-loved flavors. The perfect place to start (or the perfect gift to send).

New to CiCi's? This is where everyone starts. Four full-size bags of our bestselling cookies - the ones our customers come back for again and again. Handmade in Berkeley, sealed fresh, and ready to remind you (or someone you love) what real Italian cookies taste like.

Taste all of our bestselling flavors for just $12.50 each with our "Essential Four" bundle! Essential Four bundle has:

  • Our Original Butterhorns

  • Our Lemon 'S' Cookies

  • Our Ginger Molasses Cookies

  • Our Vanilla Sprinkle 'S' Cookies

The 'Essential Four' bundle includes 4 total bags of cookies – 28 total cookies!

$9.95 FLAT RATE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $29 to the contiguous U.S.

Because we offer our customers cookies that we bake fresh daily, we ask for up to 3 business days to ship out your order. *We are unable to ship to P.O. Boxes. Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

The Original, The Butterhorn

CiCi's first cookie starts with a rolled dough and Nana Julie's signature mix of cinnamon, sugar and walnuts.

The balance of flavors is incredible, and leaves you wanting more.

The Italian 's' Lemon Cookie

Our bestseller. Fresh lemon juice is squeezed into our frosting.

The balance of sweet and tart is perfect, if we say so ourselves.

The Perfect Ginger Molasses Cookie

Ginger. Cinnamon. Molasses. Cloves.

A perfect fall treat that perfectly works all year round.

There's no 'snap' with ours. We bake them to be perfectly chewy and soft.

And of course
The Vanilla sprinkle Cookie

Sometimes there's just nothing better than your favorite cookie with colorful sprinkles.

As with all of our cookies, we use only the best ingredients.

That's why we use real bourbon vanilla extract in our frosting and in our dough.

You may also like