Cookies for every occasion

Free handwritten gift note available

On all gift orders. Enter your note in your cart prior to checkout.

Anniversary Sale - code:15years

15% off site-wide - Ends this Sunday 10/12/25 11:59pm

CiCi’s Butterhorns make a nostalgic gift for family or friends who cherish Italian traditions. A beatiful bag of cookies tied with a red ribbon containing golden-brown Italian butterhorns cookies, alongside cinnamon sticks and walnuts, on a beige background.
CiCi's Italian Butterhorns
$12.99
Lemon lovers perfect cookie and dessert. Handmade Italian Lemon cookies on a white marble surface. Fresh lemons with leaves placed around.
CiCi's Italian Lemon Cookies
$12.99
Packaged ginger molasses cookies with a gift-worthy red bow. Cinnamon sticks and cookies on a beautiful marble surface. A perfect gift for Ginger Molasses Cookie lovers. The best cookie for the Fall.
CiCi's Italian Ginger Molasses Cookies
$12.99
CiCi's Italian Vanilla Sprinkle
$12.99
CiCi's Italian Chocolate Butterhorns
$12.99
CiCi's Italian Double Chocolate Espresso Cookies
$12.99
Our Italian Anise cookies make a perfect nostalgic gift for family or friends who cherish Italian traditions flavors. Packaged Italian Anise cookies tied with a green ribbon, displayed alongside whole anise stars on a marble surface.
CiCi's Italian Anise Cookies
$12.99
CiCi's Italian Fall Vanilla Sprinkle
$12.99

Gifting + Bundles