Please Note:

Central & East Coast orders: Priority Delivery is required to arrive in time for Easter. (Selected at checkout)

Handmade Italian Cookies Worth Sharing

Baked with real ingredients. Wrapped in love. Delivered.

The Complete Tasting

$89.99
/
  • Our most loved gift! ★ 4.95
  • Free handwritten card – add message in cart
  • 7 unique flavors, 50 delicious cookies
All 7 of our handmade flavors in one beautiful gift. Perfect for exploring our entire collection or sending to someone special.
WHAT'S INCLUDED: Free handwritten gift card. ● 1 sealed bag of each flavor – Lemon "S" Cookies ● Butterhorns ● Ginger Molasses ● Double Chocolate Espresso ● Chocolate Butterhorns ● Anise "S" Cookies ● Vanilla Sprinkle "S" Cookies

More Gift Bundles

What they'll receive

Free Handwritten Cards

A heartfelt note, written by hand, tucked into every gift—because the best presents come with a personal touch. Add message in cart.

Handmade

Made by hand, just like Nana did it—with real ingredients and a whole lot of love!

Gift-Ready

Every bag arrives topped with a bow—pretty enough to gift, special enough to keep for yourself.

Why people love sending CiCi's

Unbelievably Good!!!!!!!

These taste just like my mother's
Christmas lemon knot cookies. I
love to give packages of them
as gifts to family members and
colleagues. Everyone loves them
and I have been told told that
"the cookies never make them
home to share".

Kathleen P.
Verified Customer

Best gift to receive!

Hi! I sent CiCi's cookies to multiple people for Christmas this year. So,
I'm leaving an all-encompassing review based on feedback from those recipients. DELICIOUS! Best cookies ever! Scrumptious! Melt in you mouth goodness - and many more positive comments. CuCi's cookies are all of those things and more. I'm adding Yummy to the list

Mary B.
Verified Customer

Instant happiness!

Such a treat to receive this One of Everything box! This was for myself, but I've sent to others as gifts and instead of flowers. Instant happiness!

Brian S.
Verified Customer

Fresh and beautifully wrapped.

These cookies were fresh and delicious! I ordered some to be sent as Christmas gifts.

Rosemary D.
Verified Customer

Previously featured in the Williams-Sonoma® Holiday Gift Guide.

Perfect for any occasion

Birthdays ● Thank you's ● Thinking of you's ● Miss you Mom's! ● Client Appreciation ● Housewarming

CiCi's "Love It" Guarantee

They'll love them.

If for some reason they don't, just let us know within 30 days for a 100% refund.

Gifting FAQs

Our goal is to ship all gift orders received by 12:00PM the following business day. That being said, it may take up to 3 business days to fulfill to ensure we deliver the freshest cookies.

Please factor in your selected delivery method into your decision on when to order. UPS ground can take 1-5 business days.

  • If you'd like to order now but ship in the future, please email us at hello@cicisitaliancookies.com and we'll accommodate you.

Please enter your free gift message in your cart. There is a box labeled "Add Handwritten gift message here." This is BEFORE checkout.

45 days. That being said, our cookies are natural and handmade, and we don't use any preservatives. So while they are still delicious up to 45 days, they are the best within 1 week of delivery!

Want to make your own mix?

choose individual flavors