13 years

CiCi’s Italian Cookies started 13 years ago with one cookie recipe and a dream.

Growing up in an Italian American family, Christine Falatico Frey was always surround by love and food. Lots and lots of food. Her grandmother, Nana Julie, would make everything from scratch and when Christine would fly out to New York to spend time with her, it was typically time spent in the kitchen.

This is where Christine learned how to make CiCi's original product - the Butterhorn.

When it came time for Christine to start a family of her own, she knew she wanted to follow in Nana Julie’s footsteps and make everything from scratch. What better way to show someone you care about them than through food, right?

After Christine’s kids went off to college, she had a little more time to focus on herself and what she wanted her next adventure to be. Knowing she needed to have a passion for whatever came next, she was drawn to the theme of food. But how could she show the world love through food without having them over for dinner? And then it hit her, with a freshly baked bag of her Nana Julie’s Italian Butterhorns!

Fast forward to today and her dream has become a reality. Christine is now known as CiCi, her cookies are shipped across the country and if you’re not family working for her, you sure feel like family! CiCi’s Italian Cookies has the best employees on the planet! Their commitment to creating quality, handmade cookies is what makes CiCi’s Italian Cookies so special. Everything from how the cookie is shaped to how the bow is tied onto the bag needs to be perfect and they make sure that happens!

Christine’s daughter Brittney, son Mikey and son-in-law Casey also work for CiCi’s Italian Cookies. Brittney spent time in Corporate America before moving over to fulfill her destiny as Christine’s right hand lady. She puts her years in the financial industry to use by keeping an eye on the books while Christine is checking in on all our stores and creating new cookie recipes! 

Casey runs the kitchen proficiently, manages our staff and ships out every order of cookies. And Mikey is our creative director and photographer.

Family is everything to them, and their goal is to bring those values into the business as well!