One of Everything!

One of Everything!

Regular price$76.99

  • Satisfaction Guaranteed
  • Locally Sourced Ingredients
  • $10 Flat rate ground shipping on orders over $25

Taste each of our unique flavors at a discounted price when you purchase one bag of everything!

  • Butterhorn
  • Chocolate Butterhorn
  • Lemon
  • Anise
  • Double Chocolate Espresso
  • Ginger Molasses
  • Vanilla Sprinkle

Makes a great gift for all occasions or a delicious treat for yourself!
One of Everything includes 50 cookies total

$10 FLAT RATE SHIPPING ON ORDERS OVER $25 to the contiguous U.S.

Because we offer our customers cookies that we bake fresh daily, we ask for up to 3 business days to ship out your order. *We are unable to ship to P.O. Boxes. Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

The Original, The Butterhorn

CiCi's first cookie starts with a rolled dough and Nana Julie's signature mix of cinnamon, sugar and walnuts.

The balance of flavors is incredible, and leaves you wanting more.

The chocolate butterhorn.

For the chocolate lovers, we've added Guittard Bittersweet chunks inside, as well as drizzled on top.

The Italian 's' Anise cookie

A staple at CiCi's family's Christmas gatherings.

Anise is extremely aromatic, it pairs perfectly with an espresso or warm cup of coffee.

The Italian 's' Lemon cookie

Our bestseller. Fresh lemon juice is squeezed into our frosting.

The balance of sweet and tart is perfect, if we say so ourselves.

The Double Chocolate espresso

We use high fat cocoa powder and semi-sweet chocolate chips from Guittard chocolate for a true and rich chocolate flavor.

Paired with a hint of fine ground espresso, you can't go wrong.

Oh, and of course, we finish them with Maldon sea salt.

The Ginger Molasses cookie

Ginger. Cinnamon. Molasses. Cloves.

A perfect fall treat that perfectly works all year round.

There's no 'snap' with ours. We bake them to be perfectly chewy and soft.

And of course
The Christmas Vanilla sprinkle cookie

Sometimes there's just nothing better than your favorite cookie with colorful sprinkles.

As with all of our cookies, we use only the best ingredients.

That's why we use real bourbon vanilla extract in our frosting and in our dough.


Soooooo Delicious! I make a similar type cookie around the holidays so I thought I'd give these a try and compare the two. They are simply delicious and better than my mom's tried and true recipe! They are just delightful and not too sweet. I fear they will be gone soon...


My god, the original butterhorns might possible be the best cookies on earth. Stop reading right now and go find them.

Claudia G.

Amazingly Delicious. I've been eating these Butterhorns for years, they are absolutely wonderful. Anyone in my family who has tried them can't stop raving about them. Absolutely DELICIOUS - flaky with just the right amount of everything! Yum...

Nancy C.

Amazing cookies I love the sprinkle vanilla cookies yumm super soft and fresh!!!

Bridgid H.
Los Angeles, CA

You may also like