CiCi's Italian Butterhorns

Outline star
Outline star
Outline star
Outline star
Outline star
Filled star
Filled star
Filled star
Filled star
Filled star
$14.00
/
  • The cookie that started CiCi's
  • Flaky outside, soft caramelized center
  • Real butter, cinnamon, and walnuts
  • Add a free handwritten gift card in cart

Our Butterhorns are a cherished Christmas tradition in our home that has turned into a year-round classic.

CiCi’s Italian Butterhorns are hand-rolled from a light buttery dough and filled with cinnamon, sugar, and walnuts. Rolling them keeps the cookie center soft and caramelized during baking while the outside turns to a flaky golden brown.

Perfect with morning coffee, after dinner with guests, or as an afternoon treat. Fair warning – it's hard to stop at one.

As previously featured in the Williams-Sonoma Gift Guide and the San Francisco Chronicle.

One bag has 8 cookies and weighs 8 ounces.

FLAT RATE SHIPPING – $9.95 available on orders of 5+ bags to the contiguous U.S.

We heat seal every freshly baked bag of cookies for optimal freshness upon delivery.

Because we offer our customers cookies that we bake fresh daily, we ask for 1-3 business days to ship out your order. *We are unable to ship to P.O. Boxes. Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

The Original
The Butterhorn

CiCi's first cookie starts with a buttery dough and Nana Julie's signature mix of cinnamon, sugar, and walnuts.

The balance of flavors is incredible, and leaves you wanting more.

The technique
Rolled by hand

Rolling the ingredients keeps the inside perfectly moist while the outside crisps to a golden brown. 

The ingredients
Real Butter, California Walnuts, Pure Cane Sugar

Nana Julie added her favorite nut, fine chopped walnuts to the cinnamon and sugar mix. If you ask us, it's the perfect mix.

The spice
Cinnamon

The scent that takes us straight back to our family's kitchen in upstate New York.

Back to all Cookies