Build your own bundle

Stocking Stuffers

Choose any 10 bags for $140. Mix flavors or double up on favorites.

Order by December 15th for Christmas delivery with UPS Ground

Stocking Stuffers Bundle (10 bags)

1,000+ five‑star reviews across our cookies

10 full-size bags of handmade cookies

Every bag tied with a bow

Thoughtful gifts for teachers, neighbors, and coworkers

Regular price$140.00
/

Ten bags, your choice of flavors. Enough to fill every stocking in the house. And maybe one for you to enjoy while wrapping!

Pick any mix of our eight cookies.

Every full-size bag is handmade, sealed fresh, and tied with a bow. Tuck them into stockings, hand them to neighbors, or leave one on a teacher’s desk.

10 full-size bags. Any combination you like.

Add one free handwritten gift card in your cart.

FLAT RATE SHIPPING – $9.95 available on orders of 5+ bags to the contiguous U.S.

We heat seal every freshly baked bag of cookies for optimal freshness upon delivery.

Because we offer our customers cookies that we bake fresh daily, we ask for up to 3 business days to ship out your order. *We are unable to ship to P.O. Boxes. Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.

What our holiday gifters say

★★★★★

I've been ordering these wonderful  butterhorns for years - every Christmas - I give them as a special gift to many family members and to friends.  Every year I have many of them tell me that they can't wait to receive them again. Thank you for your continued good service and delicious treats!

Elizabeth K.
Verified Customer
★★★★★

The Christmas Joy bundle - perfect family Christmas gift!

The Christmas Joy bundle was a gift. Our friends received it as scheduled with a beautifully packaged arrangement of cookies. Fresh and delicious! We will not hesitate to order thru your website in the future! Thank you CiCi! 

P.S. My husband and I have enjoyed your cookies for a long time. We have purchased them for a few years now from our grocery store (Nugget Market).

Stephanie D.
Verified Customer
★★★★★

Fresh and beautifully wrapped

These cookies were fresh and delicious! I ordered some to be sent as Christmas gifts.

Rosemary D.
Verified Customer
★★★★★

Unbelievably Good!!!!!!!

These taste just like my mother's
Christmas lemon knot cookies. I
love to give packages of them
as gifts to family members and
colleagues. Everyone loves them
and I have been told told that
"the cookies never make them
home to share".

Kathleen P.
Verified Customer
★★★★★

These cookies are wonderful!

I bought these cookies as a gift for my cousin.  A friend told me to try one.  They were wonderful. They tasted just like my grandmother's from years & years ago. I knew my cuz'n would love them.  Ginger Molasses cookies are his very, very favorite. He loved them.  I now know what to send him for every holiday!!!  They were easy to order & were shipped quickly.  Thank you CiCi's!

Tracy P.
Verified Customer